top of page

Why Diets Fail (It’s Not Your Fault)

Writer: Melanie Briony
Melanie Briony
Nov 12
2 min read

In a recent Zoom call, we discussed The Predictive Brain and how it influences our food choices, including eating for emotional reasons, eating for pleasure and more.

Why we eat and what we eat is complex.

We discussed:

  • Eating for nourishment

  • Eating for pleasure

  • Eating because it helps us feel better

  • Eating to celebrate

  • Eating because it tastes good

  • Eating to calm down

For what other reasons do you eat?

Our past experiences influence how we respond in the present.

Our brain uses previous experiences and what we've learned from them to help make sense of what's happening right now. It does this to process information quickly, anticipate what might happen next and help keep us safe.

But if our predictions are influencing our food choices, the question is, how can we change this?

Think of yourself as having two aspects of experience:

The conscious self – the part of you that is aware, can observe, reflect, consider and make intentional choices. The unconscious self – the processes, learned associations, patterns and responses that operate outside your immediate awareness.

When we predict that a certain action will result in us feeling better, we don't necessarily consciously choose that automatic response. Often, our past experiences influence how we respond before we've had the opportunity to consciously consider what we're doing.

BUT...


Meal planning. Meals inside glass containers.

As humans, we also have access to conscious awareness.

This means we can begin to notice unconscious patterns, understand what's driving them and create the opportunity to choose a different path.

For example, perhaps you've had a stressful day and find yourself reaching for something to eat because you know it will make you feel better.

But what are you actually looking for? Comfort? Pleasure? A break? Relief?

It might be food, and that's absolutely fine. But perhaps there's something else you need.

By using self-awareness and capacity-building tools like the ones we've discussed in this programme, we can develop a deeper awareness and understanding of ourselves, our needs and our capacity.

Alongside self-compassion, we can build an internal environment that supports us in making different choices.

None of this is about labelling where we are or the decisions we make now as wrong.

It's about using our conscious awareness to notice what we'd like to change, building the internal environment that supports change, and gradually creating new ways of responding.

And remember, this isn't about taking away pleasure, overriding every automatic response or getting everything right.

It's about having more awareness, more flexibility and ultimately more choice.

I'd love to hear your thoughts on: Why Diets Fail (It’s Not Your Fault)

What comes up for you as you read these words?

Do they feel safe and supportive, or like another task to complete? If you've found this way of looking at weight loss refreshing and you'd like to learn more about working with me, hit the button bellow and let's have a chat.




Strong Like A Woman logo

 
 

Join our mailing list

Melanie Briony acknowledges the Awabakal People as the traditional custodians of the land on which she lives and works,
and honours the Ancestors who have long cared for this Country. She offers her work on these lands and waters with respect
for Elders past and present.

​

© 2026 by Melanie Briony - Strong Like A Woman
Website Design by Redcat Digital

bottom of page