top of page

Women Only Workouts Are Wasting Your Time. Try This...

Writer: Melanie Briony
Melanie Briony
Nov 11
3 min read

Updated: Nov 12

Women Are Not Small Men. But Do We Really Need Women-Only Workouts? I wish I had a dollar for every post I've read saying, "Women Are Not Small Men". Sadly, I fell for it myself, too. Believing that all the research was conducted on men and that women weren't adequately represented.


Yet, at the same time, we're being presented with proof that specific workouts are more suited to women, and we're supposed to believe these trainers because they've based their recommendations on studies involving mice?


I don't know about you, but I'm pretty sure women aren't large mice...

So yes, women are indeed not small men. But what do we actually need when it comes to fitness Do we need special women-focused workouts, or do we need something else?



Woman in a gym lifting 10kg dumbbells


Let's Talk About the Research

I've been a personal trainer since 2009. I've seen a lot come and go, and I've trained a lot of women.


What I'm about to tell you is based on my personal experience, both as a woman who lifts weights and as a trainer who works with women.


I'm not dismissing real science, but let's not forget that, apparently, there is very little research related to women and what they need when it comes to fitness.


BTW, I just want to clear something up. There is actually an ever-increasing body of research looking specifically at women and their health and fitness needs.


Yes, there is considerably more research looking at young male athletes. But the gap in the research doesn't just fail women. It fails the majority of the male population, too, because let's face it, most men are not young college athletes.


Anyhow, let me get back to what I've learned through my own personal experience as a woman who lifts in her 50s and a personal trainer who works with women.


Every Woman Is an Individual

Every woman (and man, for that matter) is a completely unique individual.


We all have very different goals, fitness levels, experience with exercise, energy and capacity levels, and different amounts of time available to train. You get the picture.


Rather than focusing on a person's gender and building a programme around those parameters, it makes so much more sense to work with the person in front of you.


  • Has this woman given birth? When? What impact has it had on her pelvic floor?

  • Is she sleeping well?

  • Is she going through menopause and struggling with her energy levels?

  • Has she sustained an injury or had a past experience with exercise that left her feeling fearful or anxious?


Think about every scenario that presents itself in life and how it might change the exercise needs of the woman in front of you.


Some of these factors will be related to being a woman, but not every woman will experience them.


Women-Only Workouts Are Wasting Your Time. Try This Instead...


Try working with:

  • Your specific goals.

  • Your preferences.

  • Your capabilities.

  • Your capacity.

  • Your individual body.

  • Your limitations.

  • Your current circumstances.


None of these are exclusively about being female, but all of them matter when it comes to succeeding with your health and fitness goals.


So yes, women are not small men. But treating every woman as a woman before treating her as an individual is just a ridiculous waste of time.


Want an Approach That Actually Works for You?

Looking for an approach to health and fitness that meets you exactly where you are?

One that takes your nervous system and capacity into consideration, looks at your goals, your needs, your abilities and your desired outcomes, and gives you what you need to succeed?

Learn more about working with me.





Strong Like A Woman logo

Join our mailing list

Melanie Briony acknowledges the Awabakal People as the traditional custodians of the land on which she lives and works,
and honours the Ancestors who have long cared for this Country. She offers her work on these lands and waters with respect
for Elders past and present.

​

© 2026 by Melanie Briony - Strong Like A Woman
Website Design by Redcat Digital

bottom of page